Three keepers. Three very different styles. One pair of gloves.

Three goalkeepers, three big performances — but only got the No.1 shirt this week but they all deserved highlighting

🧊 Jack Maclennan (Glasgow Island) — The In-Form Wall

Hugh ponders:

There’s a strong case here, but the detail matters. Across the 90 minutes, it was solid and dependable — the kind of performance teams value. The question is whether it had that extra edge, especially in terms of use of the ball, compared to the others this week.

🦁 David “Simba” Kempton (Busby AFC) — The Reactive Stopper

Simba’s performance won’t grab headlines, but it was solid across the 90. A few key saves, no mistakes, and a steady presence throughout. He gave his side something to rely on.

Hugh ponders:

There’s a strong case here, but the detail matters. Across the 90 minutes, it was solid and dependable — the kind of performance teams value. The question is whether it had that extra edge, especially in terms of use of the ball, compared to the others this week.

🧠 Antou (Burnhill FC) — The Modern Sweeper-Keeper

If this was about the all-round goalkeeper, Antou is right in the conversation.

He didn’t just deal with shots — he managed what was in front of him. Sweeping behind the defence, organising the backline, and using the ball well both short and long.

He influenced how the game was played.

Hugh ponders:

There’s a strong case here, but the detail matters. His all-round game stands out — but was he tested enough in pure shot-stopping situations compared to the others this week?

⚖️ The Verdict — Who Gets the Gloves?

It comes down to what you value.

Want a form-based shot-stopper? → Jack Maclennan

Want reliability? → Simba

Want all-round control? → Antou

But this week…

🧤 No.1 Shirt: Antou (Burnhill FC)

Why?

Because he added more than the basics. Organisation, decision-making, and use of the ball all gave his side more control.

Leave a comment

Quotes we like

“The Saturday morning GCFA & the Sunday GDSFC are 2 superb examples of the thriving Amateur football scene when leagues are well run .”

~ Player involved in both leagues